European Payments Initiative (Part 2)

The European Payments Initiative (EPI) faces significant challenges that could impact its likelihood of success, especially considering the failures of previous initiatives like P27. Here are the key factors influencing EPI's potential success.

Challenges and Risks

1. Stakeholder Alignment and Commitment

Successful pan-European payment initiatives require strong alignment and stakeholder commitment. Previous initiatives like P27 failed partly because of conflicting priorities among participating banks and insufficient commitment.

In the case of P27, Danske Bank's involvement with MobilePay led to conflicting interests, contributing to the project's failure. Similarly, if EPI's participating banks do not fully commit or have conflicting interests, they could face similar issues.

2. Clear Value Proposition and Market Fit

Many previous initiatives lacked a compelling value proposition that met market needs. EPI must offer a clear and attractive value proposition to both consumers and merchants.

The Monnet Project failed because it did not provide a distinct advantage over existing payment methods. For EPI to succeed, it must demonstrate clear benefits such as lower transaction fees, enhanced security, or superior convenience compared to existing solutions.

3. Consumer and Merchant Adoption

Changing consumer behavior and gaining merchant acceptance are critical for the success of any new payment method. This is particularly challenging in Europe, where payment preferences vary significantly across countries.

iDEAL succeeded in the Netherlands due to strong local adoption, but similar schemes in other countries did not achieve the same success. EPI must navigate these regional differences and incentivize both consumers and merchants to adopt its platform.

4. Operational and Governance Challenges

Large-scale initiatives often suffer from operational complexities and governance issues. Effective management and clear governance structures are essential.

P27 faced operational challenges and an overly ambitious scope, which led to its reassessment. To steer the project effectively, EPI must ensure a realistic and manageable scope and robust governance.

5. Funding and Investment

Adequate funding and a sustainable revenue model are crucial. Many previous initiatives failed due to insufficient investment and unclear revenue models.

EPI has already seen the number of participating banks reduce from 33 to 13, raising concerns about its financial backing and long-term viability. Ensuring sufficient funding and a clear path to profitability is essential for EPI's success.

Potential for Success

1. Political and Regulatory Support

EPI has strong backing from the European Commission and the European Central Bank, which can provide significant advantages in terms of regulatory support and market confidence.

The political support for EPI can help overcome regulatory hurdles and gain trust from stakeholders, which was a challenge for previous initiatives like the Monnet Project.

2. Focused Scope and Realistic Goals

By narrowing its focus to instant payments and a digital wallet, EPI's goal is more realistic and achievable than the broader ambitions of previous initiatives.

The shift in focus from creating a rival card network to developing a unified digital wallet and instant payment solution allows EPI to concentrate on a specific, high-demand area, increasing its chances of success.

3. Leveraging Existing Infrastructure

EPI plans to build on the existing SEPA Instant Credit Transfer (SCT Inst) scheme, which provides a solid foundation and reduces the complexity of creating a new infrastructure from scratch.

Utilizing SCT Inst allows EPI to offer instant payments across Europe more efficiently, addressing a clear market need and leveraging existing systems to facilitate adoption.

Conclusion:

While the European Payments Initiative faces significant challenges similar to those that led to the failure of previous initiatives like P27, several factors work in its favor. Strong political support, a focused scope, and leveraging existing infrastructure enhance its chances of success.

However, achieving stakeholder alignment, ensuring a clear value proposition, and driving consumer and merchant adoption will be critical. The ultimate success of EPI will depend on its ability to navigate these challenges effectively.

Providers such as Trustly, Brite, and Tink can rest easy for now….